jcpenney pricing strategy case study

Lessons from the failure of J.C. Penney’s new pricing strategy

Aug 5, 2021

Lessons from the initial failure of J.C. Penney's new pricing strategy. You must understand your customer's price conditioning and experiment.

Price Intelligently

SaaS pricing and monetization experts

Join our newsletter for the latest in SaaS

By subscribing you agree to receive the Paddle newsletter. Unsubscribe at any time.

At one time or another, we have all fallen victim to a store’s advertisement of the “Biggest Sale Event Ever”. We’ve found ourselves looking at a shirt originally marked $50 and buying it for $25, because that seems like a good deal – who doesn’t love 50% off? Even though this tactic has worked so well for businesses in the past, J.C. Penney made a bold move in January to rid their stores of all discounts, sales, and coupons for “ fair and square ” pricing. Unfortunately, just like that $25 shirt wasn’t really a bargain, J.C. Penney’s new approach hasn’t worked out quite yet, leading them to get even bolder with their pricing strategy in the next few weeks. Let’s dig into the years of pricing science they’re flying in the face of and see what we can learn:

Traditional retailers utilize promotional, fake, and anchored prices

To better understand J.C. Penney’s shortcomings, let’s first examine how a typical retail pricing strategy breaks down. For years, retailers, no matter what time of day or year, have offered sales and advertisements that lure bargain-drooling customers in the doors. Retailers use a combination of promotional pricing, fake pricing, and price anchoring to form a comprehensive psychological pricing strategy that creates a pricing trigger that minimizes the sales cycle significantly.  For instance, when faced with a 60% off, 12 hour only coupon that reduces a $1,200 winter coat to $400, you can’t help but rush to the store to buy it, even if it is 95 degrees out.

A few things are happening here. For one, the $1200 acts as an anchor price that psychologically forces you to realize you’re getting an enormous deal at the $400 price point. Plus, the promotion limiting the time the offer is available forces you into an impulse. In actuality, you’re not that special, because these sales never truly end. Almost no one ever pays full price. In fact, studies show that people are much more inclined to pay $25 for an item valued at $50, than paying for the same item without a sale at $25. It’s all about the “price framing” of a product that creates a perceived value, which all leads to the excitement of getting a good deal

WARNING: Those last two links are to some reaaaaal nerdy stuff, so if you want to read some work from the Larry Bird and Michael Jordan of Price Economics click through. If you do end up reading one or both, then let us know by tweeting to @priceintel with the hashtag #TalkNerdyToMe.

You need to understand your customer’s price conditioning

So, where did J.C. Penney go wrong? Well, while we admire their attempt to change, they attempted to destroy over a century’s worth of price conditioning consumers have been through with department stores and pricing in general. They weren’t completely off base, as consumers with more and more access to information (comparison shopping engines, consumer reports, etc.), are beginning to realize that the value of products is determined much differently than a sticker would suggest. Yet, assuming that most soccer moms (and dads) wouldn’t fall prey to the colorful print ads tucked within the comics section in the Sunday paper, overlooks how much the majority of consumers value “winning” the retail game. Simply, deflating the perceived value causes customers to value the actual product less.

With a 20% sales drop, J.C Penny’s flight in the face of traditional retail pricing, has failed, at least in the short-term. CEO Ron Johnson insists that the company will continue with this method, even though experts expect the retail chain to gradually return to offering frequent sales and promotions.

You know your business, we know pricing

Price Intelligently's team of monetization experts work with you to combine strategy and data to solve complex business problems and accelerate your growth.

What can your business learn from a retail price experiment gone awry?

We’ll be tracking J.C. Penney’s trajectory closely as they continue to iterate on their pricing strategy, but their initial failure can teach you the following, regardless of what you’re selling:

1. You need to understand what motivates your customer.  If they are conditioned to using discounts, coupons, and promotions, then send them offers. If they know the strike-out price on your website is just a game, then don’t patronize them with one.

2. It’s ok to experiment with your pricing strategy.  J.C. Penney’s bold move could have paid out significantly within a different context. Take  Everlane , for example, a company that calls out exorbitantly priced clothing basics and sells everything at a flat rate under $100.

3. Communicating price changes is key.  J.C. Penney heavily advertised the concept of their new pricing strategy, “Fair and Square Pricing,” but when their implementation involved color categories, flow-charts, and was anything but simple. If you’re making price adjustments, make them easy to understand, and your customers will follow.

For more on pricing strategy, download our  Pricing Strategy ebook  or speak to one of our analysts.

Related reading

Brought to you by:

J.C. Penney's "Fair and Square" Pricing Strategy

By: Elie Ofek, Jill Avery

As a he gets ready to release 2nd quarter 2012 results, Ron Johnson, the new CEO of department store J.C. Penney, is reconsidering the dramatic changes he initiated for the business model and brand…

• Length: 27 page(s)
• Publication Date: Sep 21, 2012
• Discipline: Marketing
• Product #: 513036-PDF-ENG

What's included:

• Teaching Note
• Educator Copy

$4.95 per student

degree granting course

$8.95 per student

non-degree granting course

Get access to this material, plus much more with a free Educator Account:

• Access to world-famous HBS cases
• Up to 60% off materials for your students
• Resources for teaching online
• Tips and reviews from other Educators

Already registered? Sign in

• Student Registration
• Non-Academic Registration
• Included Materials

As a he gets ready to release 2nd quarter 2012 results, Ron Johnson, the new CEO of department store J.C. Penney, is reconsidering the dramatic changes he initiated for the business model and brand image of his company. A new pricing scheme he put in place in February, dubbed "Fair and square", was a central component of the new strategy. The scheme initially had three pricing tiers and eliminated typical sales promotions in an attempt to simplify the shopping experience for consumers; thus moving J.C. Penney off its previous high-low pricing practice. Other components of the new strategy included a new store layout, the inclusion of several well-known brands, and having special lines designed by well-known designers. However, troubling first quarter results that continued into the summer months seemed to indicate that J.C. Penney shoppers, accustomed to receiving JCP Cash coupons and circulars advertising the week's specials, were slow to embrace the new pricing format and began leaving the retailer in droves. Under enormous pressure to turn things around as the all-important back-to-school and holiday shopping seasons were imminent, Johnson decided to make adjustments to the initial pricing scheme that were set to go into effect August 1st. Were these changes enough to turn things around? Should Johnson stay the course on the other elements of his repositioning efforts? Is Johnson's experience in setting up Apple stores helping or hurting him as he tries to achieve his goal of making J.C. Penney "America's favorite store"?

Sep 21, 2012 (Revised: Jan 4, 2013)

Discipline:

Harvard Business School

513036-PDF-ENG

We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve your experience, including personalizing content. Learn More . By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies and revised Privacy Policy .

• SUGGESTED TOPICS
• The Magazine
• Newsletters
• Managing Yourself
• Managing Teams
• Work-life Balance
• The Big Idea
• Data & Visuals
• Reading Lists
• Case Selections
• HBR Learning
• Topic Feeds
• Account Settings
• Email Preferences

J.C. Penney: Ditch the Risky Pricing Strategy

• Rafi Mohammed

While I was dubious about J.C. Penney’s switch to its Fair and Square Everyday Low Pricing Strategy, even I have been surprised at how miserably the strategy is faring so far. During its first quarter under the new pricing strategy, same store sales dropped by 18.9%, store visits decreased by 10%, and the average spend […]

While I was dubious about J.C. Penney’s switch to its Fair and Square Everyday Low Pricing Strategy , even I have been surprised at how miserably the strategy is faring so far.

• Rafi Mohammed is the founder of Culture of Profit, a consultancy that helps companies develop and improve their pricing strategies. He’s also the author of The Art of Pricing: How to Find the Hidden Profits to Grow Your Business (Crown Business, 2005) and The 1% Windfall: How Successful Companies Use Price to Profit and Grow (HarperCollins, 2010). cultureofprofit

Partner Center

• Harvard Business School →
• Faculty & Research →
• April 2013 (Revised October 2014)
• Teaching Note
• HBS Case Collection

J.C. Penney's 'Fair and Square' Pricing Strategy

• Format: Print
• | Language: English
• | Pages: 32

About The Authors

Jill J. Avery

Related work.

• January 2014
• Faculty Research

J.C. Penney's 'Fair and Square' Strategy (C): Back to the Future

• J.C. Penney's 'Fair and Square' Strategy (C): Back to the Future  By: Elie Ofek, Jill Avery and Jose B. Alvarez
• J.C. Penney's 'Fair and Square' Pricing Strategy  By: Elie Ofek and Jill Avery

Product details

• Skip to primary navigation
• Skip to main content
• Skip to primary sidebar
• Skip to footer

MMR Strategy Group

Lessons in Pricing Strategy from JCPenney

May 15, 2013 by Bruce Isaacson

JCPenney’s New Pricing Strategy

In 2012, JCPenney, under the leadership of new CEO Ron Johnson, who had run stores at Apple, undertook a significant change in its pricing strategy. The new pricing strategy eliminated promotions and focused on selling recognized brands. Under the prior promotions-based pricing strategy, prices were marked up so there would be room for promotional discounts. By contrast, the new “Everyday” pricing strategy set prices lower, eliminating or reducing the need for what used to be sale prices. There were other changes as well. For example, prices no longer ended in 9 or 7 (such as $9.99); instead, whole figures were used when pricing items. Also, price tags now showed just one price and no longer listed the “manufacturer’s suggested retail price,” which had previously provided a higher comparison price illustrating how much the product could be sold for elsewhere.

The retailer also made significant changes in merchandise assortment. JCPenney focused on mini-stores within larger stores, such as those for Martha Stewart products. Note: JCPenney has been in a court battle with Macy’s over the right to sell the Martha Stewart “JCP Everyday” line of home goods. The trial underscores how competitive the middle-market home goods category is and how one brand like Martha Stewart can matter. Read more .

Back to the Future for Pricing Strategy

As you have no doubt read elsewhere, the new pricing strategy never gained traction with consumers. Sales declined steadily over time. The chain lost $3.3 billion in sales in the first year of Johnson’s turnaround plan. Its net loss in the quarter ended Feb 2, 2013, widened to $552 million from $87 million a year earlier. Annual revenue slid 25% to $13 billion, the lowest since at least 1987.

Under pressure, the CEO announced the company would move away from the “Everyday” pricing strategy and return to coupons and weekly advertised sales. The change came too late for Mr. Johnson, who left the company in early April 2013, at which time the prior CEO returned.

Lessons from JCPenney for Pricing Strategy

JCPenney’s experience with a non-promotional (or Everyday) pricing strategy has many lessons. In my opinion, these lessons include the following:

• The change eliminated reference pricing for consumers. Yet another reason the “Everyday” pricing strategy encountered difficulty is because JCPenney eliminated the manufacturer’s suggested retail price from its price tags. This suggested retail price may have offered what marketers call a “reference price.” Some consumers use reference prices to judge quality and value; without reference prices, consumers may have had a hard time judging the value of JCPenney’s merchandise, which was often undifferentiated. (Also, by switching from prices that end in “9” to prices that end in”0”, could the chain have lost another signal that the prices are discounted?)

JCPenney has changed pricing strategy, but its future is unclear

JCPenney has now added back reference prices for their Arizona store brand items, so they will again show comparison prices from other retailers. In his first big move, the new CEO tapped $850 million from a credit line and announced the company was looking into other ways to strengthen JCPenney’s balance sheet, and provide breathing room to develop and execute a new plan.

The new credit may lend JCPenney enough time to re-boot. However, the fates of Kmart , Sears and Circuit City are a reminder that the odds against JCPenney succeeding as an independent entity are low. Then again, retailing is fascinating in part because it is so unpredictable.

Dr. Bruce Isaacson President MMR Strategy Group

Privacy Overview

Small Business Trends

Jc penney’s marketing strategy: mistakes and lessons.

In Kentucky we have a saying that sometimes a person is “too big for their britches,” and I think the same can be said for businesses as well. As one of the oldest clothing brands in the U.S. (over a century), it’s a shame that JC Penney has been experiencing recent hardships.

According to Forbes , JC Penney has seen their sales drop by as much as 20 percent in a single quarter. Even worse is the fact that their rebranding and marketing efforts have done nothing to stem the loss in revenue. Their “ Fair and Square ” pricing actually turned people away from the store, not into it. Ouch.

Why You Should Pay Attention to JC Penney

It might seem counterintuitive to learn marketing lessons from a company that’s struggling, but that’s exactly what we should do. You see, JC Penney is at a tipping point. What they do today will determine the fate of the brand – if not the company itself. We can learn from their marketing strategies that backfired as well as the strategies that help the company regain its former strength.

Mistakes and Lessons from JC Penney’s Marketing Strategy

A sale is only a sale if it’s a sale.

Consumers love a good sale. This is what drives them into the store throughout the year. JC Penney tried to take advantage of this by enacting a permanent sale called “Fair and Square” pricing. However, since this became a permanent sale, it really wasn’t a sale and people had no reason to come into the store compared to a one-day daily, quarterly or annual sale.

The technique backfired so badly that JC Penney actually reintroduced “normal” sales. The point of a sale is finding a great deal and it’s not a great deal if it’s commonly available.

Know Your Audience

An illuminating survey recently revealed the fact that consumers don’t like JC Penney’s clothes. The situation here should be obvious: No matter how hard JC Penney tries to market their products, if people don’t like them, then the marketing simply won’t work.

Thus, instead of focusing solely on your ideal demographic, spend some energy researching whether your target audience will even like the product at all.

Beware Your B2B Partnerships

Business-to-business relationships are almost always a good thing unless there’s some sort of falling out, and JC Penney had a big one. They signed an exclusive “Martha Stewart Deal” that was expected to save them. JC Penney would have the exclusive right to distribute Stewart’s products. The only problem? Stewart already has a similar contract with Macy’s .

There are two lessons from this scenario:

• First, don’t put all your eggs in one basket. No B2B should be a make-or-break endeavor. Your brand should be able to stand on it’s own and any collaboration is simply a bonus.
• Second, thoroughly vet your endeavors before embarking on them. It’s bad enough that the Stewart deal may fall through, but it’s worse that this has to happen under public scrutiny.

Eliminate Unneeded Weight

When it was announced that JC Penney’s CFO, Ken Hannah, dumped 10 million of the company’s shares , the financial world was in shock. Hannah explained, “It just wasn’t worth the effort.” The company had other things they wanted to focus on during the turnaround process. Likewise, eliminate unneeded distractions during your marketing campaign.

Consider the Marketing Trends

While some marketing strategies are evergreen in nature, others are newer and on the verge of becoming mainstream. Recently, JC Penney began eliminating stereotypes in their advertising .

For instance, a recent Father’s Day ad showed two men (presumably together) with their children in JC Penney clothes. Regardless of what you think about this social issue, JC Penney deserves commendation for their risk to stay relevant.

It’s too bad that it’s (usually) about price.

Well, it’s actually about perception-a consumers perception.

Their purchases-our purchases, have to feel right.

That tends to happen a lot when things are on sale.

JCP’s should have stopped their bad marketing train a year ago.

The Franchise King

What about the PRO GAY GARBAGE? ELlen Degenerate as spokesperson? That is what KILLED them!!! Go get all of your sales from GAYS!! NORMAL families are no longer interested!!

Us ‘normal’ families are just fine with them. Businesses aren’t missing your shrinking hate-family minority

Oh please. “hate-family”. Yes, because someone doesn’t agree on the ridiculous “everyone jump on the hey-we’re-gay wagon” means that they must hate. Such silly logic Andrew.

It wasn’t the gay marketing tactic, or anything like that, their merchandise was cheap, fall apart cheap. No wonder their pricing was so low. I used to shop Penney’s alot, but t-shirts that don’t survive a washing, clothes designed for 18 year olds and just cheap China stuff is not what people want. They have K-Mart and Wallmart for that.

© Copyright 2003 - 2024, Small Business Trends LLC. All rights reserved. "Small Business Trends" is a registered trademark.

TheBigMarketing.com

JCPenney Marketing Strategy 2024: A Case Study

JCPenney, a renowned name in the retail industry, has adopted a dynamic marketing strategy to thrive in the ever-evolving landscape. By leveraging the power of omni-channel and digital marketing, they have successfully engaged customers across various platforms.

A crucial aspect of their strategy is customer segmentation, allowing them to tailor marketing campaigns to different target audiences. Through careful brand positioning and analysis of their competitors, JCPenney has cemented its place in the market, while also building customer loyalty.

Moreover, JCPenney’s marketing mix , encompassing product, price, promotion, and place, has played a pivotal role in their success. By keeping a close eye on market trends and consumer behavior, they have implemented strategic initiatives that have set them apart from their competitors.

Key Takeaways:

• JCPenney has embraced omni-channel and digital marketing to engage customers effectively.
• Customer segmentation and targeted marketing campaigns have aided in brand positioning.
• JCPenney’s marketing mix plays a vital role in their competitive advantage.
• Competitive analysis enables JCPenney to stay ahead in the market.
• Customer loyalty is a key focus for JCPenney’s marketing strategy.

JCPenney’s Historical Retail Strategy

JCPenney, a prominent player in the retail industry, has undergone significant shifts in its historical retail strategy to adapt to evolving consumer behavior and market dynamics. Initially, the company positioned itself as a one-stop shop for middle-class consumers by offering a wide range of merchandise at affordable prices. This competitive positioning aimed to capture a substantial market share and establish JCPenney as a preferred destination for customers.

However, as the retail industry became more competitive and consumer preferences changed, JCPenney recognized the need to adapt its strategy to stay relevant in the market. The company embarked on a strategic transformation, revamping its store layouts, enhancing its online presence, and re-evaluating its product offerings.

The revamp of store layouts aimed to create a more modern and engaging shopping environment, catering to the evolving expectations of consumers. JCPenney incorporated innovative designs, improved visual merchandising, and introduced experiential elements within their stores. This transformation not only enhanced the overall shopping experience but also differentiated JCPenney from its competitors.

In line with the growing importance of e-commerce, JCPenney recognized the need to embrace digital channels. The company invested in developing a robust online platform with user-friendly interfaces and seamless navigation. By leveraging technology, JCPenney expanded its reach and engaged with a broader customer base.

Furthermore, JCPenney re-evaluated its product offerings to align with changing consumer demands and preferences. The company conducted extensive market research to identify emerging trends and consumer needs. Through this process, JCPenney curated a more diverse and relevant product assortment, catering to a wider range of customer segments.

Key Elements of JCPenney’s Historical Retail Strategy:

• Positioning as a one-stop shop for middle-class consumers
• Store layout revamp to create an engaging shopping environment
• Enhanced online presence to cater to the growth of e-commerce
• Re-evaluation of product offerings based on market trends and consumer preferences

This strategic transformation aimed to strengthen JCPenney’s competitive positioning by differentiating the brand and enhancing its value proposition. By embracing market dynamics and adapting to consumer behavior, JCPenney has positioned itself for continued success in the ever-evolving retail industry.

Challenges in the Retail Landscape

The retail landscape faces numerous challenges, driven by e-commerce disruption, shifting consumer behavior, technological advancements, pricing pressures, and supply chain disruptions.

• E-commerce Disruption: The rise of online shopping has significantly impacted brick-and-mortar retailers, leading to decreased foot traffic and reduced sales and profitability.
• Shifting Consumer Behavior: Consumers are increasingly seeking personalized experiences and seamless omnichannel interactions. Retailers must invest in advanced customer relationship management systems and tailored marketing strategies to meet these evolving expectations.
• Technological Advancements: Rapid technological advancements necessitate that retailers keep pace with digital transformation. Failure to embrace technological innovations may result in a loss of competitiveness and relevance in the market.
• Pricing Pressures: Price transparency and comparison shopping have intensified in the retail landscape. Retailers face the challenge of developing competitive pricing strategies to attract and retain customers amidst heightened price sensitivity.
• Supply Chain Disruptions: Global events and trade policies can significantly impact supply chains, leading to unpredictable inventory challenges. Agile supply chain management and risk mitigation strategies are vital to navigate supply chain disruptions effectively.

Visual Representation: Retail Landscape Challenges

Implementation of new initiatives.

JCPenney, a leader in the retail industry, has recognized the importance of implementing new initiatives to stay competitive in the market. By understanding consumer demands and market dynamics, they have strategically revamped their product offerings and invested heavily in enhancing their digital capabilities. This proactive approach allows JCPenney to adapt to the ever-changing retail landscape and maintain their position as a customer-focused retailer.

One of the key areas where JCPenney has implemented new initiatives is their online platform. With the rise of e-commerce and changing consumer behavior, having a strong online presence is crucial. JCPenney has made significant advancements in their online platform, ensuring a seamless and personalized shopping experience for customers. By leveraging technology, they have improved website functionality, optimized search and navigation, and implemented personalized product recommendations. These digital capabilities not only enhance the online shopping experience but also increase customer engagement and satisfaction.

In addition to their online platform, JCPenney has also focused on transforming their in-store experience. They understand the importance of providing a unique and engaging environment for customers. By revamping their store layouts and displays, JCPenney creates a visually appealing and immersive shopping experience. They have also introduced interactive elements, such as digital screens and touchpoints, to engage customers and provide them with a personalized shopping journey.

To demonstrate the strategic implementation of these new initiatives, here is a table showcasing the key changes JCPenney has made:

By successfully implementing these new initiatives, JCPenney has achieved a competitive positioning in the market. They have responded to changing consumer demands, leveraged market dynamics, and enhanced their product offerings both online and in-store. These strategic changes have enabled JCPenney to remain relevant in the retail industry and provide a seamless and satisfying shopping experience to their customers.

Outcomes and Results

The successful implementation of new initiatives by JCPenney has led to positive outcomes and results. The strategic shifts have resulted in improved business performance, including increased revenue and profitability. This indicates that JCPenney’s efforts to adapt to changing market dynamics and consumer demands have been successful.

One key indicator of the effectiveness of these initiatives is the boost in customer satisfaction. JCPenney has implemented measures that have resulted in higher Net Promoter Scores, demonstrating a higher level of customer satisfaction and loyalty.

The outcomes and results highlight the importance of strategic realignment and innovation in driving success in the retail industry. By addressing evolving consumer demands and market dynamics, JCPenney has been able to strengthen its competitive position and meet the needs of its customers.

Overall, the outcomes and results of JCPenney’s new initiatives are a testament to the company’s commitment to improving business performance and customer satisfaction in a rapidly changing retail landscape.

Lessons Learned and Takeaways

JCPenney’s experience provides valuable lessons and takeaways for retailers navigating the ever-evolving retail landscape. By staying attuned to consumer preferences and market dynamics, retailers can ensure their relevance and competitiveness in the industry. Maintaining a clear and differentiated market positioning that aligns with brand identity and consumer expectations is crucial to stand out in a crowded retail landscape.

Retailers should proactively assess and recalibrate their strategies in response to market changes, enhancing their resilience and adaptability. This requires a deep understanding of consumer preferences, market dynamics, and emerging trends. By leveraging these insights, retailers can make informed decisions to drive their business forward.

Furthermore, brand identity plays a vital role in shaping consumer perceptions and loyalty. Building a strong and consistent brand identity helps retailers establish a unique position in the market, enabling them to differentiate themselves from competitors. Retailers should focus on delivering a consistent brand experience across all touchpoints to reinforce their brand identity and create a lasting impression on consumers.

In summary, the key lessons learned from JCPenney’s experience include:

• Staying attuned to consumer preferences and market dynamics
• Maintaining a clear and differentiated market positioning
• Proactively assessing and recalibrating strategies
• Building a strong and consistent brand identity

Key Takeaways

Retailers can drive success in the dynamic retail landscape by incorporating the following takeaways:

• Continually monitor and adapt to changing consumer preferences and market dynamics
• Invest in market research and data analysis to gain deep insights into consumer behavior
• Develop a unique and compelling brand identity that resonates with target customers
• Create an omnichannel strategy to provide seamless and personalized customer experiences
• Stay agile and flexible in responding to market shifts and emerging trends

By applying these lessons and takeaways, retailers can position themselves for success in a highly competitive and rapidly evolving retail industry.

Financial Analysis of JCPenney

JCPenney’s financial analysis provides valuable insights into the company’s performance over the years. Despite facing various challenges in the retail industry, including changing consumer behavior and market dynamics, JCPenney has experienced a decline in revenue and profitability. The negative earnings per share and decreased book value per share reflect the financial pressure the company has been under.

One of the notable challenges JCPenney faces is managing its cash flow, which affects the company’s ability to control costs and maintain liquidity. Furthermore, the stock price of JCPenney has been volatile, reflecting the uncertainties in the market and the impact on investor confidence.

To address these financial difficulties, JCPenney must focus on effective cost management and pricing optimization. By implementing strategies to streamline operations and reduce expenses, JCPenney can improve its financial performance and ensure long-term sustainability.

Financial Highlights

Effective cost management is crucial for JCPenney’s financial recovery. By identifying areas of inefficiency and implementing cost-saving initiatives, JCPenney can optimize its operations and generate positive cash flow. Furthermore, pricing optimization strategies can help enhance profitability and improve customer value perception.

It is important for JCPenney to carefully analyze its financials and make data-driven decisions to navigate the challenging retail landscape. By focusing on improving revenue, profitability, cash flow, and cost management, JCPenney can strengthen its financial position and position itself for future success.

JCPenney’s Turnaround Strategy

JCPenney, in an attempt to reverse its declining performance, has undergone several CEO changes and implemented various pricing and sales approaches. The company initially introduced the “everyday low prices” strategy and created in-store boutiques to enhance the shopping experience and attract customers.

However, these strategies failed to resonate with customers, leading to a decline in sales and a negative market perception. As a result, JCPenney has shifted gears and returned to promotional pricing and discount coupons.

The company recognizes the importance of catering to customer preferences and aims to rebuild customer loyalty and improve performance by implementing these revised pricing and sales approaches.

This change in pricing and sales approaches reflects JCPenney’s responsiveness to customer preferences and market dynamics. By reverting to promotional pricing and discount coupons, the company aims to rebuild customer trust, enhance sales, and improve its market perception.

JCPenney’s Strategies for Recovery

JCPenney is implementing a range of strategies to recover from its recent performance decline. These strategies include:

• Product Diversification: JCPenney is expanding its product offerings to cater to different customer segments. By diversifying their product lines, they aim to attract a wider range of shoppers and increase sales.
• Discounts and Promotions: The reintroduction of discounts and promotions is a key strategy for JCPenney. By offering competitive prices and enticing offers, they aim to attract price-sensitive customers and drive traffic to both their online and physical stores.
• Online Promotions: JCPenney is leveraging the power of social media platforms to improve their online promotions. Through strategic social media campaigns and targeted advertisements, they are enhancing their online presence and reaching a larger audience.
• Home Department Focus: JCPenney is placing emphasis on the home department by partnering with exclusive designers and home décor specialists. By curating unique and trendy home products, they aim to position themselves as a go-to destination for home essentials and decor.

These recovery strategies are designed to restore customer satisfaction and loyalty, ultimately leading to improved financial performance.

Product Diversification and Home Department Partnerships

By implementing these strategies, JCPenney is taking proactive steps towards recovery and positioning itself for future success in a dynamic retail landscape.

In conclusion, JCPenney’s strategic adaptation to the challenges of the evolving retail landscape has been instrumental in maintaining its competitive advantage. The retail industry continues to face significant challenges, including e-commerce disruption, shifting consumer behavior, and technological advancements. However, JCPenney has proactively responded by implementing an omni-channel marketing strategy that focuses on customer engagement.

Through product diversification, JCPenney has enhanced its offerings, catering to the evolving preferences and demands of customers. They have also implemented targeted promotions to attract and retain their customer base. In addition, JCPenney has invested in improving both the in-store and online experience, creating a seamless and engaging shopping journey for their customers.

While challenges persist, JCPenney’s commitment to strategic adaptation and customer engagement has positioned them for future success in a dynamic industry. By staying attuned to changing consumer behavior and market dynamics, JCPenney has ensured its relevance and competitiveness. With their proactive approach and dedication to meeting customer demands, JCPenney remains well-positioned to navigate the evolving retail landscape and continue thriving in a highly competitive market.

What is JCPenney’s marketing strategy?

JCPenney has developed a comprehensive marketing strategy that focuses on omni-channel marketing, digital engagement, customer segmentation, and targeted marketing campaigns.

How has JCPenney adapted to the changing retail landscape?

JCPenney has transformed its store layouts, enhanced its online presence, and re-evaluated its product offerings to strengthen its competitive positioning and value proposition.

What challenges does the retail landscape face?

The retail landscape faces challenges such as e-commerce disruption, changing consumer behavior, technological advancements, price transparency, and supply chain disruptions.

What new initiatives has JCPenney implemented?

JCPenney has focused on revamping its product offerings, enhancing its digital capabilities, and creating a more engaging in-store experience to adapt to consumer demands and market dynamics.

What outcomes have JCPenney’s new initiatives produced?

JCPenney has seen improved revenue, profitability, and customer satisfaction as a result of its strategic realignment and ability to meet evolving consumer demands.

What lessons can be learned from JCPenney’s experience?

Retailers should stay attuned to consumer preferences, maintain clear market positioning, and proactively adapt their strategies to succeed in a dynamic retail landscape.

What is JCPenney’s financial analysis?

JCPenney has experienced declining revenue and profitability, negative earnings per share, and decreased book value per share, impacting cash flow and stock price volatility.

How has JCPenney implemented a turnaround strategy?

JCPenney has diversified its product offerings, reintroduced discounts and promotions, improved online promotions, and focused on the home department to restore customer satisfaction and loyalty.

How is JCPenney planning to recover from its performance decline?

JCPenney is focusing on product diversification, discounts, online promotions, and partnerships in the home department to improve financial performance and regain customer loyalty.

What can we conclude from JCPenney’s marketing strategy?

JCPenney’s marketing strategy has helped the company navigate challenges in the retail landscape, adapt to changing consumer demands, and maintain a competitive advantage.

Related Posts

Editorial Team

Intel marketing strategy 2024: a case study, jetblue marketing strategy 2024: a case study.

JC Penney Pricing Strategy Report

Introduction, background of jc penny and its department store industry, jc penny’s pricing strategy, whether the pricing strategy will work, the pricing strategy and the company’s merchandising approach.

Marketing is a critical component in business performance. JC Penny is one of the companies that have recognized the significance of effective pricing. The company recently developed a new pricing strategy (Anderson, 2012). The fundamental objective of this strategy is to increase the customer base. Apart from this, the company seeks to establish a strong and renowned brand.

Companies have undertaken transformative initiatives to enhance their competitiveness. Observably, most clients would be attracted towards goods that sell at lower and competitive prices. This paper analyzes the recent pricing strategy of JC Penny. Additionally, it examines the likelihood of success of the new pricing strategy.

JC Penny is remains as a holding business organization. The company got its incorporation in 2002. Evidently, the firm operates as a major retailer. It has approximately 1102 departmental stores. These stores are present within 49 states (D’Innocenzio, 2012). The basic business processes involve the sale of merchandise and other critical services to different clients. These processes are procured through the departmental stores.

However, the company also applies online marketing to sell most of its products and services. The company deals in a wide range of goods. These are meant for beauty and cosmetic purposes. Some of these include apparels, different types of footwear, and accessories. Moreover, it is also evident that the company deals in jewelry products and other properties meant for interior design.

It is important to note that these diverse products are found within different departmental stores owned by the company. Nonetheless, the company has certain stores that act as a one-stop point for shopping to all customers. There are several kinds of distribution initiatives undertaken within the store facilities.

Generally, the company has made tremendous achievements. For instance, it obtained the global entitlements for the “Liz Claiborne family of trademarks” and associated intellectual property in 2008 (Anderson, 2012). In addition, the company has been able to acquire the U.S and Puerto Rico “rights for the Monet trademarks and related intellectual property.”

It is evident that the United States contains very sensitive customers. Pricing is a key factor in the manipulation of client behavior and consumption patterns. JC Penny undertook a bold step towards revamping its pricing strategy. This process involved the termination of coupons that were earlier issued by the company to the clients. This is despite the fact that most of its clients had gotten used to the coupon system of product promotion (D’Innocenzio, 2012).

According to most market analysts, this initiative was a great blunder on the side of JC Penny. Of course, the result would be a significant decline in the number of customer visits to the company stores. There are observable undertakings by the company to apply a strategic pricing mechanism to attract back its clients. For example, the manufacturer’s prices have been aligned to those of the JC Penny. This is a transformative undertaking to attract and expand the overall customer base.

The stores are also not left behind in these initiatives. There are efforts aimed at increasing the extent of geographic markets. The stores have begun regular vendor promotion practices. The technique involves collaborating with other vendors who have already placed the company’s products in the market for sale. The company wants to transform into a routine and low price departmental store. The change is forecasted to be vital for the company’s growth and development.

The recent “fair and square” pricing technique is expected to lure many customers throughout the year (Anderson, 2012). This undertaking seeks to transform the company from being specifically “a sale –on-promotion” entity. In the new system, customers are urged to attend or visit the stores persistently all year round. The operation through department stores offers unique opportunities to the consumers. This is because an individual has the capacity to buy expensive goods at acceptable rates of discount.

Several reactions have emerged from the recent pricing strategy undertaken by JC Penny. It is clear that the strategy is not likely to work and succeed. There are several factors to be considered in this decision (Anderson, 2012). The strategy does not favor and takes into account the influential elements within the external environment. Notably, the radical change does not consider the feelings of the customers.

The customers were used to a particular pricing system. Therefore, this eminent change in pricing needed some time to be introduced. Economically, most people are keen to compare the prices of similar products. It is evident that even with a discount; most customers would not believe that the products are cheap. Such convictions might negatively affect the operation of this new pricing strategy. The price changes do not consider the fluctuations and interrelations of consumer behavior.

Flexibility and constant innovation are some of the critical steps in managing consumer behavior. A rigid pricing strategy would not be appropriate for the attraction of new consumers. The pricing strategy may be prone to potential threats from external competitors. There are many competitors within the clothing and design industry within the U.S (D’Innocenzio, 2012). It is necessary for all companies to adopt innovative technology and guided decision-making process.

In times of low economic conditions, most buyers remain reserved. This means that they do not rush to buying. Particularly, this refers to buying goods that have very high price tags. This is regardless of whether the good is to be bought through an agreeable discount. It is evident that several environmental factors interplay. Consequently, they have a significant role in influencing the purchasing power of customers.

It is evident that the pricing strategy to be adopted by the company complements its new promotion strategies. Foremost, the strategy allows for a wide room of informed choice by the customer. The proposed product promotion mechanism involves the use of different media sources.

In essence, this enables the advertisement and promotion of different products (Anderson, 2012). Therefore, several customers have diverse points from which they can choose their products. Specifically, it is important to use different promotion initiatives. Although there are obvious similarities, a considerable period would be appropriate to increase the sales volume.

Globalization and advanced technological applications have increased the level of competition. Most companies recognize the significance of effective pricing in marketing. Ideally, different pricing mechanisms may be applied to attract new customers. Notably, such strategies might be crucial in retaining the new clients. Expert advice and consultations are mandatory in the development of effective pricing strategies. Additionally, organizations must apply analytical tools while transforming their marketing strategies.

Anderson, M. (2012). JC Penney tweaks pricing strategy, reversing course again . Web.

D’Innocenzio, A. (2012). J.C. Penney slashing prices on all merchandise . Web.

• Chicago (A-D)
• Chicago (N-B)

IvyPanda. (2024, February 13). JC Penney Pricing Strategy. https://ivypanda.com/essays/jc-penney-pricing-strategy/

"JC Penney Pricing Strategy." IvyPanda , 13 Feb. 2024, ivypanda.com/essays/jc-penney-pricing-strategy/.

IvyPanda . (2024) 'JC Penney Pricing Strategy'. 13 February.

IvyPanda . 2024. "JC Penney Pricing Strategy." February 13, 2024. https://ivypanda.com/essays/jc-penney-pricing-strategy/.

1. IvyPanda . "JC Penney Pricing Strategy." February 13, 2024. https://ivypanda.com/essays/jc-penney-pricing-strategy/.

Bibliography

IvyPanda . "JC Penney Pricing Strategy." February 13, 2024. https://ivypanda.com/essays/jc-penney-pricing-strategy/.

• Poor Leadership at J.C Penney
• JC Penney Company's Marketing Strategies
• J.C. Penney Company: Pricing and Marketing Plan
• JC Penney & Ron Johnson: The Failed Leadership
• J.C. Penney's Management Style and Innovation
• J.C. Penney Case Study Analysis
• JC Penney Corporation's Environmental Forces
• Management at J C Penney Company, Inc
• Red Lobster's and J.C. Penny's Marketing Advice
• Management and Organisational Behavior: JCPenney
• Marketing in Modern Businesses
• Gaining a Competitive Edge
• Description of a Marketing Plan
• Competitive Point-of-Difference
• Collabo: Product Development

• About   General Information Permissions Company Collaboration Case Competitions Best Case Award Press Releases Access Options Submission Guidelines

Berkeley Haas Case Series

The Berkeley Haas Case Series is a collection of business case studies created by UC Berkeley faculty

J. C. Penney: Activist Investors and the Rise and Fall of Ron Johnson

Learning objectives.

Pub Date: Jun 29, 2014

Revision Date: Jun 23, 2014

Discipline: Marketing

Subjects: Retail, Leadership, Marketing, Consumer behavior, Consumers, Market positioning, Pricing, Pricing strategy

Product #: B5808-PDF-ENG

Industry: Retail trade

Geography: United States, Texas

Length: 14 page(s)

Recommended

A new collection of business case studies from Berkeley Haas

The aim of the Berkeley Haas Case Series is to incite business innovation by clarifying disruptive trends and questioning the status quo.

• Order Status
• Testimonials
• What Makes Us Different

JC PENNY FAIR & SQUARE PRICING STRATEGY Harvard Case Solution & Analysis

Home >> Harvard Case Study Analysis Solutions >> JC PENNY FAIR & SQUARE PRICING STRATEGY

JC PENNY FAIR & SQUARE PRICING STRATEGY  Case Solution

Problem Diagnosis

            A new pricing scheme had been put in place by Ron Johnson, the CEO of JC Penny in February 2012. However, the first quarter results did not come up to expectations. Therefore, as he was getting near to release the results for the 2 nd quarter of 2012, he was considering a number of dramatic changes to be made to the brand image and the business model of the company. The central theme of the repositioning strategy was the switching away from the existing high low pricing strategy of the company. The objective behind the new pricing strategy was to simplify the shopping experience for the JC Penny customers and make it more straightforward for the customers of the company to shop.

This strategy was a massive shift from the current high low pricing strategy of the company. However, the first quarter results of 2012 had showed that the new strategy was not able to achieve that had been projected. Therefore, this case deals with the analysis of the fair and square pricing strategy and to evaluate that whether this strategy was misguided or it was simply the matter of execution of the strategy at the right time. Ron Johnson had to consider a number of things and he had also planned many changes to the new pricing scheme. This case emphasized on whether these changes were enough to save the company or not.

Case Analysis

            A number of issues have been evaluated in order to develop a set of strategic alternatives for Ron Johnson. Finally, the recommended strategy has been designed for JC Penny.

Evaluation of Fair & Square Repositioning Strategy

            The Fair and Square pricing strategy is a value based proposition where the objective of Ron Johnson is to capture more value from the everyday low prices (EDLP) and to simplify the shopping experience of the customers and change their perceptions of the stores about just thriving on the basis of promotions and deals. However, the issue with this strategy is that price is not a way to capture or create value from the customers. Another critical mistake made by Ron Johnson was that the company did not conduct a market research to grab an understanding of the customer perceptions about the new pricing strategy. The secondary efforts of this new pricing scheme consisted of the sales structure, store design, spokesperson and the logo. The new store design and the logo work out well for this strategy as they are literally square.

However, as the company would also be the number of the high end brands along with the specialty store layout which is quite confusing for the customers as the store also wants to keep the prices fairly low, thus it lowers the perceived value for the customers. The new sales structure is also ineffective as the management did not take any step to explain the sales team about their critical role of sales experts. As there has been no communication with the sales team therefore, they are sending the message to them that they are less valued whereas the success of this strategy depends on them. Another flaw in the strategy is the nonexistence of the promotion component of the marketing mix in the form of a spokesperson.

Ellen DeGeneres is a completely fresh face for the brand, therefore, without any market research it is quite difficult to say that whether the customers would trust or connect with Ellen to buy products under the new scheme. The spokesperson might have proved to be effective, but the lack of the communication with the customers about how the high low pricing method was complex and the new pricing scheme created value for them created confusions among the customers and less bargains, negative perceptions and higher prices for the customers......................

This is just a sample partial case solution. Please place the order on the website to order your own originally done case solution.

Related Case Solutions & Analyses:

Hire us for Originally Written Case Solution/ Analysis

Like us and get updates:.

Harvard Case Solutions

Search Case Solutions

• Accounting Case Solutions
• Auditing Case Studies
• Business Case Studies
• Economics Case Solutions
• Finance Case Studies Analysis
• Harvard Case Study Analysis Solutions
• Human Resource Cases
• Ivey Case Solutions
• Management Case Studies
• Marketing HBS Case Solutions
• Operations Management Case Studies
• Supply Chain Management Cases
• Taxation Case Studies

More From Harvard Case Study Analysis Solutions

• Tim Keller at Katzenbach Partners LLC (C)
• Sothebys.com
• Medical Foods Inc.
• Telemedicine Case Analysis
• Responding to 21st Century Financial Crisis
• Note on Pricing and Public Policy
• Landlocked Homes: Catching a Falling Knife

Contact us:

Check Order Status

How Does it Work?

Why TheCaseSolutions.com?